You’re Right, I Must be an Idiot

Don’t you love it when non-Christians, atheists, gay-rights activists, etc. reference the Bible and tell you that you’re reading it wrong? “Most of the Old Testament was negated and set straight by Jesus” and “You go out and stone a bunch of people, I’ll be living to please Jesus in the meantime” are on the list of things I’ve been told. I was told “the Old Testament pretty much doesn’t matter anymore” and the evidence for this claim was Jesus responding to the question about the greatest commandment. Kudos for knowing Jesus’ answer to that question; Love the Lord you God with all your heart, soul, mind and strength. A second is just like it, love your neighbor as yourself. This was an example of Jesus setting things straight.

The problem is that Jesus responded by quoting the Old Testament. Love the Lord your God with heart, soul, mind, strength is Deuteronomy 6:5 and love your neighbor as yourself is Leviticus 19:9. Jesus has fulfilled the Law and the Prophets and not done away with anything. It is not uncommon for people to suggest I read the Bible for myself and quit believing everything I’m told, or that quoting the Bible doesn’t make me a Christian. The fact that I need to “move forward” and/or “progress” into the 21st century seems to get repeated. Just like after a few Facebook comments I’m going to reexamine my Christian life and suddenly realize the past 26 years have been a waste and that progression (agreeing with changing social norms) is the most important thing. “Have you even read the Bible?” No, I somehow manage to accumulate 21 years in youth ministry, teach every age level of Sunday School, be ordained first as a deacon then as a minister without having read the Bible. My blog is filled with pages and pages of theology, apologetics and sermons that I don’t know anything about whatsoever.

Okay, I’m gonna slow down my roll and share a graphic. A little knowledge can be a dangerous thing, but follow a few paths on this flowchart which started the dialog I’m getting all lathered up over.

Screenshot 2014-04-02 at 9.01.11 PM

1) The response to “the Old Testament says so” is to bring up food and clothing laws. Those regulations were specifically about being Jewish. Those things are kosher. Moral law is carried forward into the New Testament.

2) The response “the New Testament says so” is explained away by telling us the N.T. doesn’t really say homosexuality is wrong, unless we happen to be reading the Apostle Paul, who wrote MOST of the New Testament. And since he said a woman should not assume authority over a man we can ignore everything he said about homosexuality in Romans 1. According to this chart.

3) God ordained marriage in the Garden of Eden when Eve was made for Adam. The earth is populated today in a way that it was not in Eden or after the flood so reproduction is no longer a basis for choosing sexual partners. According to the chart anyway. And everything Paul said about marriage, couples, raising children etc. we are ignoring because of a couple of other things he said that we don’t like.

4) The Bible definition of marriage + Jesus said so. “I’d like to quote what Jesus said about gay marriage, but he never said anything.” That is a lie if one has ever been told.

Jesus repeated what Moses said in Genesis: “Have you not read that he who created them from the beginning made them male and female, and said, ‘Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh’? (Matthew 19:4-5 ESV) Those are Old Testament words, spoken by Jesus to a New Testament audience. It is the biblical definition of marriage, found in both Testaments and confirmed by Jesus Christ.

But here’s the thing…

When Satan tempted Jesus he quoted some scripture as well, although perhaps somewhat misguided. The Pharisees had studied and memorized the Law, but still missed the point. Jesus said they kept the letter of the Law but not the spirit of the Law. When Jesus quoted scripture some marveled at his understanding and others wanted to kill him. Eventually they did. Jesus was the Word made flesh and they accused him of blasphemy. Jesus never committed a sin but was accused of breaking the Sabbath, eating with unwashed hands, lying, and being possessed with demons!

They will misquote scripture, interpret scripture wrongly, and tell followers of Jesus they don’t know anything about Jesus. They will demean the Christian faith, all religion and even Jesus himself. We are commanded to love them; but they sure do make it hard sometimes. “Those people” we are arguing with? They’re the mission field.

As Jesus was nailed to the cross, he prayed for those crucifying him. Of the Jewish leaders and Roman soldiers, he prayed “Father forgive them for they know not what they do.” We are told in Philippians to have the same mind in us that Christ had. That is our mission and the only way to please God is to accept it.

5 thoughts on “You’re Right, I Must be an Idiot

  1. Great post! Misquoting, leaving out what God said, etc. is the oldest lie in the world, starting in the Garden of Eden. I can see why you were inspired to write about this poster. It just shows how little people know about a book they’ve never read.

  2. Um. Yes, people with a low level of theological knowledge come out with the arguments why God welcomes gay marriage, but so do serious Christians, even theologians. I am sorry you are irritated debating with people who don’t know the Bible, but perhaps you should start debating the theologians (not me, necessarily).

    I am not clear how you would take “two men should not lie together” out of Leviticus 20, but not the bit about stoning them. When you say it was about being Jewish, do you mean that Leviticus was written after the Assyrian conquest of the Northern kingdom?

  3. “Jewish” is perhaps not the right word, but one I thought everyone would understand. To be technically correct, they were Hebrews before entering Canaan and Israelites after conquering the land and establishing the nation of Israel. The word Jew is not used in the Bible until the Book of Ester, originated from the southern kingdom of divided Israel, a.k.a. Judah.

    The Hebrews/Israelites would have stoned both men. Morality laws continue into the New Testament; Jesus repeats Moses’ definition of marriage, Paul speaks to homosexuality in Romans 1. The penalties listed in Leviticus, Numbers and Deuteronomy were for the nation of Israel. Today we live in the Age of Grace, not under the Law. When the woman caught in adultery was brought to Jesus he said to let the one without sin cast the first stone. We are to discern evil but not judge in this present age; all will one day be judged by the only righteous judge. At this time the wicked appear to prosper. But it is appointed unto man to die and after this the judgement.

  4. Jesus recognized the sin and told the woman to repent and sin no more. The issue is repentance. Homosexuality, like every sin, can be forgiven. But if a person argues it is not sin then he or she will not be asking forgiveness. That is unrepentant sin. Jesus did not condemn the woman in John 8; but if she did not repent and continued to sin then one day he will.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.